Eigner's Bake Shop

Y Z 2 months ago

Came in erev shabbos just to look around and walked out with 3 different cakes. I couldn’t wait for shabbos to try it, so I had to buy every flavor of the mini rugalach to try in the car home and they were delicious.

Avraham Spira 5 months ago

Absolutely incredible bakery. Every single thing we tried was fresh, beautifully made, and tasted amazing. The pastries were flaky and rich without being too heavy, the challahs were perfectly baked, and the desserts looked as good as they tasted. You can tell they really care about quality and consistency. The store was spotless, the staff was patient and friendly, and the whole experience felt upscale without being pretentious. Easily one of the best bakeries in the Toms River/Lakewood area. Definitely worth going out of your way for.

Samuel Eitan Cohen 5 months ago

Nothing but YUMMINESS TO MY BIG TUMMINESS!!! From the first time I walked in to the final second, the owner took such good care of me that I felt I was a guest for Shabbat. She was like, have a piece of this on the house and as Jews we ❤️ FREEBIES, even if we shouldn't indulge, and I was MESMERIZED!!! From seeing Challah, the kind you see in Israel to browsing around with seconds before closing time for Shabbat, I walked out with a ROLADA aka 7 Layer Chocolate Cake. I grew up on these foods, and being pre diabetic doesn't help. Had a few bites tonight and was sent back to my childhood in Ramat-Gan, Israel, so a HUGE TODA = Thank you for being you, you now have a future customer for life, and all my friends near and far are 🤤 🤤 🤤. Shavua tov from Robbinsville, NJ, where I technically came for 15 Potato burekas next door at ISHTABACH, which is AMAZING too, and spent close to $70 on both locations within 5 minutes 😆 🤣. Never come in hungry is all I'm going to say 😀 😊.

Mordechai Geberer 10 months ago

Being able to visit, purchase, and truly enjoy a kosher pastry in a boutique and stand alone bakery is becoming more and more rare, especially in the Lakewood community. Much of today's kosher baked goods is mass produced and the taste reflects that. Eigners is different. Everything is authentic and homemade basically from start to finish. When you bite into that apple turnover or taste the napoleon you're enjoying homemade and fresh ingredients including the non-canned apple filling, the puff pastry, and pastry creme. The owners are friendly and gracious always enjoy interacting with their customers and sharing their passion for what they do. They only make what they themselves like and do it 💯 Great great place! Oh, you gotta taste their marble cake. Best out there!

ed Edited 2 years ago

10/01/2024: First time visit. The staff is friendly and helpful. Inside is VERY neat and well laid out. The display cases, in particular, are well set up in the manner their goods are presented. The Red Top cupcakes were VERY tasty but not sweet. The cake was vanilla. Not sure what to call the "muffins" but their flavor was a delight. I'll be back! Thank you.